Re: Cell Research
Nico Kadel-Garcia <nkadel@comcast.net> wrote:
|| <cadcoke3@yahoo.com> wrote in message
|| news:1153958511.931567.64720@s13g2000cwa.googlegroups.com..
|||
||| Nico Kadel-Garcia wrote:
|||| These are not babies: we're talking a few cells that were
|||| never viable fetuses, never had a brain stem, never even
|||| had a nervous system.
|||
||| We normally call the union of sperm and egg conception..
||| the
||| beginning. A fertalized egg, if simply placed in the proper
||| nurturing enviroment will grow to an adult human. That is
||| very different from an individual sperm or blood cell.
||
|| No, most of them will *die*. Only a few survive long enough
|| to start interesting things like brainstems.
||
|| And a gleam in my eye looking upon my wife, placed in the
|| appropriate nurturing environment, will lead to a family of
|| hundreds of descendants. Shall the gleam in my eye have the
|| same rights and protections as the hundreds of living
|| descendants? I think not!
||
||| Another noteworth item I've read about regards the number
of
||| permutations between the DNA of sperm and egg upon their
||| union; it
||| exceeds the number of atoms estimated to exist in our
||| universe. This unions is about as special an event as you
||| can imagine.
||
|| So are the first several hundred digits of pi, or the exact
|| genetic structure of an amoeba. Uniqueness is hardly unique.
||
||| Our generation is not the first one to find "non human"
||| sources of
||| tissue to cure diseases. But, we look back at that prior
||| generation of healers with horror.
||
|| OK, now you're just being silly. Willow tree bark for
|| headache, bandages for bleeding, curare for tetanus, oranges
|| for scurvy, etc. all have "non-human" sources of material for
|| curing diseases. Or do you mean specifially for transplants?
|| The whole concept of transplants was viewed with horror when
|| first developed, but it's turned into a lively business (with
|| a recent reporter by a former secretary of state of Canada,
|| reporting Chinese Falun Gong members being harvested for a
|| trade in transplantable organs, eek!)
||
|| The stem cells are harvested and cultured. A sufficient
|| supply for culturing (according to the report I read 10 years
|| ago) a're easily havested from natural abortions, dead and
|| failed babies who otherwise are burned as medical waste, or
|| in a few cases buried. I can't think of a better use for that
|| tissue.
||
|| There is a potential slippery slope: actual living, moving,
|| talking people have previously been classified as "non-human"
|| for trivial reasons and denied rights for trivial reasons,
|| but in this case, we're not talking about people. We're
|| talking about medical waste.
There are also the 1.3 million plus abortions per year performed
in the U.S. These fetuses are disposed of, in most cases these
are not viable humans. Why can't these fetuses also be used for
research?
--
It's a place to listen and read for a while, called lurking. Get
an idea of the tone of the community. Learn who the trolls and
troublemakers are and ignore them.
|