PA Health Systems

Web Forum-style access to our favorite medical and health related Usenet groups for our customers and visitors
Not affiliated with state of Pennsylvania or any health care provider in Pennsylvania.
Registration is free! Edit your profile Calendar Find other members Frequently Asked Questions Search this Forum:

ExamVouchers.com - CompTIA discount exam vouchers - save money

Sponsor: Cert21.com
Free Online practice tests



Pages (10): [1] 2 3 4 5 6 » ... Last »
 
Last Thread   Next Thread

Author
Post New Thread    
willytex@yahoo.com



Samadhi?
The word Samadhi is found in the early Buddhist leterature,
specifically the Anguttara Nikaya IV.94 of the Samadhi Sutra of Shakya
the Muni, namely Gautama of Kapilavastu, India's first historical
yogin. There is a long history of the use of this word in early
pre-sectarian Buddhism, in the Chan tradition and in Zen Buddhism. In
the index of the Visuddi Magga, for example, there are over twenty-five
references to Samadhi that need to be read in context.

However, the word Samadhi is not found in any of the 10 Upanishads
commented on by Shankara Acharya. This is no small mattter and cannot
be passed over, for if, as you say, the attainment of Samadhi is
central to the experiential verification of the Vedanta, one would
expect the phrase to occur in the sacred texts, would one not?

Samadhi: 1. Sanskrit (Sa=FAma=FAdhi) n. Jap., sanmai or zanmai 2.
Nirvana, Parinirvana 3. from the root word 'Sam', to establish, make
firm. 4. A conscious experience that lies beyond waking, dreaming, and
deep sleep. 5. A non-meditative meditative mental equipose.




Old Post 06-15-05 05:19 PM
   Edit/Delete IP: Logged
Sevenhundred Elves



Re: Samadhi?
willytex@yahoo.com wrote:

> The word Samadhi is found in the early Buddhist leterature,
> specifically the Anguttara Nikaya IV.94 of the Samadhi Sutra of Shakya
> the Muni, namely Gautama of Kapilavastu, India's first historical
> yogin. There is a long history of the use of this word in early
> pre-sectarian Buddhism, in the Chan tradition and in Zen Buddhism. In
> the index of the Visuddi Magga, for example, there are over twenty-five
> references to Samadhi that need to be read in context.
>
> However, the word Samadhi is not found in any of the 10 Upanishads
> commented on by Shankara Acharya. This is no small mattter and cannot
> be passed over, for if, as you say, the attainment of Samadhi is
> central to the experiential verification of the Vedanta, one would
> expect the phrase to occur in the sacred texts, would one not?
>
> Samadhi: 1. Sanskrit (Saúmaúdhi) n. Jap., sanmai or zanmai 2.
> Nirvana, Parinirvana 3. from the root word 'Sam', to establish, make
> firm. 4. A conscious experience that lies beyond waking, dreaming, and
> deep sleep. 5. A non-meditative meditative mental equipose.

I'm sorry that I don't remember this as well as I would like to, but I
have read somewhere that the yogic tradition used to be a subculture or
even a contraculture to Brahminism. Maybe this could explain why the
Vedas don't use that (really very technical) term. I'm not certain at
all about this, or whether whatever book I once read it in was very
authoritative, but perhaps it could be worth looking into, if you could
find any references to it.

BTW, I always thought Samadhi meant "sameness meditation" from a root
meaning same, and another root which also "Dhyana", meditation, comes
from.

S.



Old Post 06-15-05 05:19 PM
   Edit/Delete IP: Logged
anon



Re: Samadhi?
samadhi has nothing to do with jnana aka bodhi.

<willytex@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:1118754887.493628.118150@o13g2000cwo.googlegroups.com..
However, the word Samadhi is not found in any of the 10 Upanishads
commented on by Shankara Acharya. This is no small mattter and cannot
be passed over, for if, as you say, the attainment of Samadhi is
central to the experiential verification of the Vedanta, one would
expect the phrase to occur in the sacred texts, would one not?







Old Post 06-15-05 05:19 PM
   Edit/Delete IP: Logged
willytex@yahoo.com



Re: Samadhi?
Sevenhundred Elves wrote:
> I always thought Samadhi meant "sameness meditation" from a
> root meaning same, and another root which also "Dhyana",
> meditation, comes from.
>
The key word here is cessation -  an experience of epistemological
reflection. The most ancient sustained expression of yogic ideas is
found in the early discourses of the historical Buddha, thus
Patanjali's  conception of freedom is related to the ancient Buddhist
view that the source of suffering is the craving for permanence in a
universe of impermanence.

Both the 'Four Noble Truths' and the 'Eightfold Path' articulated in
the Buddha's first discourse are elements that underlie the yoga
system. Two striking examples of this are Patanjali's use of the word
nirodha in the opening definition of yoga as citta-vrtti-nirodha, that
is, 'Yoga is the cessation of the turnings of thought' and the
statement that "all is suffering, dukkha, for the wise man."

Dukkha, suffering, and nirodha, cessation, are crucial terms in
Buddhist vocabulary and the doctrine of suffering is the core of what
Buddhists believe the Buddha taught after gaining enlightenment.
Patanjali's ashtang eight-limbed practice is parallel to the
eight-limbed path of Buddha.




Old Post 06-15-05 05:19 PM
   Edit/Delete IP: Logged
willytex@yahoo.com



Re: Samadhi?
anon wrote:
> samadhi has nothing to do with jnana aka bodhi.
>
The Buddha's Eightfold Path to Bodhi (enlightenment)

8. Right Samadhi

Pali samma samadhi: A mental factor present in every state of
consciousness.

The Eightfold Path:
http://buddhism.about.com/library/bleightpath.htm




Old Post 06-15-05 05:19 PM
   Edit/Delete IP: Logged
LawsonE



Re: Samadhi?

<willytex@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:1118807915.961280.140910@o13g2000cwo.googlegroups.com..
> Sevenhundred Elves wrote: 
> The key word here is cessation -  an experience of epistemological
> reflection. The most ancient sustained expression of yogic ideas is
> found in the early discourses of the historical Buddha, thus
> Patanjali's  conception of freedom is related to the ancient Buddhist
> view that the source of suffering is the craving for permanence in a
> universe of impermanence.
>
> Both the 'Four Noble Truths' and the 'Eightfold Path' articulated in
> the Buddha's first discourse are elements that underlie the yoga
> system. Two striking examples of this are Patanjali's use of the word
> nirodha in the opening definition of yoga as citta-vrtti-nirodha, that
> is, 'Yoga is the cessation of the turnings of thought' and the
> statement that "all is suffering, dukkha, for the wise man."
>
> Dukkha, suffering, and nirodha, cessation, are crucial terms in
> Buddhist vocabulary and the doctrine of suffering is the core of what
> Buddhists believe the Buddha taught after gaining enlightenment.
> Patanjali's ashtang eight-limbed practice is parallel to the
> eight-limbed path of Buddha.
>

The concept of "spirit" as in "breath" appears in virtually all the
languages of the world, from Chinese to Latin to Japanese to Hopi.

The deepest state of Samadhi is the breathless state where your "true
spirit" is. I suspect that the Hopi word for spirit didn't come from some
samadhi technique brought to America by Buddhists.

IOW, the "experience" called "samadhi" predates Buddhism, and is probably
found within all mystical/spiritual/religious traditions at some point in
their development since it is certainly referenced by the languages that
evolved along with these traditions.





Old Post 06-15-05 05:19 PM
   Edit/Delete IP: Logged
anon



Re: Samadhi?

<willytex@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:1118808201.728663.42060@g43g2000cwa.googlegroups.com..
> anon wrote: 
> The Buddha's Eightfold Path to Bodhi (enlightenment)
>
> 8. Right Samadhi
>
> Pali samma samadhi: A mental factor present in every state of
> consciousness.
>

samadhi is concentration practice (ie, one-pointedness, or exclusion of
everything else).

bodhi is the culmination of awareness (ie, choiceless awareness) where one
is even aware of the seed of existence.





Old Post 06-16-05 03:53 AM
   Edit/Delete IP: Logged
anon



Re: Samadhi?
samadhi is one of the paths leading to bodhi. it is not a necessary
requirement. neither is it sufficient.

also, most esoteric teachings were passed secretly to students in the yoga
path. the upanishads do not mention vipassana type of meditation either. yet
the buddha got his bodhi by that method. so the method existed before the
buddha and must have been well-regarded in is time to be followed by him. it
just shows the principal upanishads are discourses on jnana and not yoga or
practice.

vedanta is a path of discrimination and direct awakening, unlike yoga which
is a gradual practice.

the vedas also do not mention the main practice in modern hinduism - bhakti.

<willytex@yahoo.com> wrote in message
news:1118754887.493628.118150@o13g2000cwo.googlegroups.com..
However, the word Samadhi is not found in any of the 10 Upanishads
commented on by Shankara Acharya.





Old Post 06-16-05 03:53 AM
   Edit/Delete IP: Logged
Dave ©¿©¬



Re: Samadhi?
"LawsonE" <nospam@nospam.com> wrote in message
news:23Ore.6117$i81.3560@fed1read05..
>
> <willytex@yahoo.com> wrote in message
> news:1118807915.961280.140910@o13g2000cwo.googlegroups.com.. 
>
> The concept of "spirit" as in "breath" appears in virtually all the
> languages of the world, from Chinese to Latin to Japanese to Hopi.
>
> The deepest state of Samadhi is the breathless state where your "true
> spirit" is. I suspect that the Hopi word for spirit didn't come from some
> samadhi technique brought to America by Buddhists.
>
> IOW, the "experience" called "samadhi" predates Buddhism, and is probably
> found within all mystical/spiritual/religious traditions at some point in
> their development since it is certainly referenced by the languages that
> evolved along with these traditions.
>

Howdy!

IMHO: All discussion about what samadhi is, isn't or might be is pointless.

Samadhi is an entirely different plane of perception. The best description
of samadhi that I can give is:

Samadhi is an experience of reality in which all superimpositions, points of
reference and comparison have been removed. (Same principle as my contention
that one can not discuss reality.)

IOW: You will immediately recognize it when you get there!

Once you have experienced it, the only way to communicate the experience is
to say the word. If a twinkle of understanding appears in the listeners eye,
all is understood -- if not, then any attempts to convey the experience
(sensation?) are pointless.

--
Dave ©¿©¬

http://www.howdydave.com






Old Post 06-16-05 01:54 PM
   Edit/Delete IP: Logged
tantricone@aol.com



Re: Samadhi?
Dave =A9=BF=A9=AC wrote:
> Howdy!

Howdy.

> IMHO: All discussion about what samadhi is, isn't or might be is pointles=
s=2E
>
> Samadhi is an entirely different plane of perception. The best description
> of samadhi that I can give is:
>
> Samadhi is an experience of reality in which all superimpositions, points=
of
> reference and comparison have been removed. (Same principle as my content=
ion
> that one can not discuss reality.)
>
> IOW: You will immediately recognize it when you get there!
>
> Once you have experienced it, the only way to communicate the experience =
is
> to say the word. If a twinkle of understanding appears in the listeners e=
ye,
> all is understood -- if not, then any attempts to convey the experience
> (sensation?) are pointless.

Nice.  That's it, exactly.

The word is merely a label for something that cannot possibly
be expressed in words, the classic finger pointing to the moon.
When you point, some people think fondly of their experiences
with the moon and smile.  Others think you're giving them the
finger.

Unc




Old Post 06-16-05 01:54 PM
   Edit/Delete IP: Logged




Pages (10): [1] 2 3 4 5 6 » ... Last »
All times are GMT.
The time now is 04:43 AM.   
Pages (10): [1] 2 3 4 5 6 » ... Last »
Post New Thread    


Yoga archive | Real Estate forum

Featured sites

Featured site: MCSE, MCSD, CompTIA, CCNA training videos



Popular medical Forums
Diabetes forum Asthma Support Herpes Support
Arthritis forum Migrane Support Hepatitis-C support
Allergy Lyme Disease HIV AIDS Support Forum
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome Politics and Medicine Pharmacy
Depression Support Depression Medications Nutrition forum


Print this thread Show a Printable Version | Email this thread Email This Page to Someone! | Receive updates to this thread

Forum Jump:
Rate This Thread:
 


Health Information forum archive

 
 We recommend: Database administration help | Exam Notes | Web Design forum
  Copyright 2003 - 2006 PA Health Systems  Term of Service  

Offshore web hosting by serverslease.net

Powered by: vBulletin
Copyright ©2000, 2006, Jelsoft Enterprises Limited.