Re: Yoga "mysticism"
I am familiar with the quantum brain theory, but don't pay much
attention to it as there is absolutely no proof of it. Even if it is
true, it does not change anything. There is no scientific theory, even
quantum theory, that can justify a belief in reincarnation. That is
the crucial point. No one knows exactly how consciousness works, but
we do know for sure it relies on chemistry to work. You can put any
"enlightened" person to sleep by injecting them with drugs, lowering
their blood pressure, or removing oxygen or glucose from their blood.
My guess is that consciousness is just complexly woven chemistry. Even
bugs have consciousness, so the consciousness circuit exists in even
small animals and is not that complex. One Russian scientist claimed
to have built a conscious computer by making computer chips that mimic
the human brain cell. His claim may have been balcony, but who knows
what scientists will bring in future years. I would not be surprised
if artificial consciousness is possible.
If you read the current scientific papers written on consciousness you
will not find any bigger pile of horse dung anywhere. They use allot
of ten dollar words for ten cent ideas, and jump from one obscure
reference to another, all without really saying anything. Thus, it is
easy to tell from what has been written so far that no one knows
anything and that they are all just bluffing to get grant money. If
you really know how something works you can state it simply and
clearly. Scientists can describe the TV camera like qualities of the
human brain, but not consciousness itself. There is an organic TV in
your brain, but what is watching the TV? The quantum brain papers are
even worse because they have no scientific test data to back up any of
their beliefs. It is all just based on wild speculation and a desire
to find something sexy and mysterious, so they can go on believing in
reincarnation or spirit or whatever their religious trip is.
The universe IS a mysterious place and matter is energy and energy is
UNKNOWN. For example, there is no scientific explanation as to why and
how a room dedicated to meditation practice builds up a vibe. It may
be some kind of simple electrical charge or it may be something new to
science. That said, there is no evidence to suggest a separable soul,
let alone reincarnation. If something is true you can test for it. If
you test the soul-reincarnation theory at multiple points you will find
it fails the test at every point. If you test the no-soul,
no-reincarnation theory at multiple points, you will find it passes the
tests with ease at every single point.
Soul is a theory and no-soul is a theory. I would be pleased to find
that one day someone discovers proof of a soul and reincarnation, as I
find life fun and I would be happy to come back for another go-round.
I am not anti-soul by emotional makeup and I believed in
soul-reincarnation for over 35 years. That is a long time to believe
something. The point is all my beliefs fell apart due to overwhelming
evidence the soul theory is fantasy and not fact. There is allot of
evidence to suggest that religions, which are all cults, and gurus are
using those well meaning fantasies to make money and mind control the
masses.
I would love to be proven wrong on this matter, but I doubt that will
happen as all the evidence is against my former belief in
soul-reincarnation. I got suckered into believing it because I was
naively and wrongly impressed with the credentials of all those great
sages who believed in it. Then I finally realized I was part of a long
chain of belief that was based on nothing but wishful thinking. The
great heroes of religion are not that great, and the "occult" is just
part of the world of human imagination.
Christopher Calder
http://home.att.net/~meditation/ - home page
|